I'm Kaylan, leadership educator, podcaster & speaker

What are you searching for?

Reading suggestions

Crafting a 90-Day Onboarding Plan

Job Postings that Attract Top Talent

Mapping Your Leadership Style

Hiring a Team

Avoiding Common Onboarding Pitfalls: 7 Mistakes to Sidestep When Building a Team

June 15, 2021

Congrats on successfully navigating the hiring process and welcoming a fresh face to your team! This is an exciting chapter, not only for the newcomer but for your entire team. Before you get your welcome committee organized, let’s dive into the critical — yet often underestimated — process of onboarding a new team member.

Why is onboarding so crucial? It’s the catalyst that kick-starts the team dynamic, setting the tone for the newest member! Drawing from my personal experiences and frequent pitfalls I’ve observed in helping clients, I’ll share my own trials and errors as well as practical solutions to navigate a strong onboarding plan for your new team member!

Entrepreneur writing out her onboarding process for her team members in her journal.

Onboarding Sets the Tone for New Team Members

Hiring is just the first step in building a formidable team; onboarding is where the magic happens! It defines the team culture and sets the expectations for our newest teammates. Regrettably, onboarding often gets overshadowed by the hiring process (though this needs to be stellar, too!), reduced to a procedural afterthought. However, it should be a dynamic and engaging process, strategically designed to set your new team members up for success. By implementing a robust onboarding process, you can foster loyalty, decrease turnover rate, and integrate the new hire seamlessly into the existing team.

Remember, hiring doesn’t culminate with a signed offer letter; the true test lies in the subsequent 90 days of their tenure. This integration phase holds an astounding 70% importance in the entire hiring process.

Mistakes to Avoid When Onboarding

  1. Haste Makes Waste: Embarking on the onboarding journey without a well-laid-out plan is a recipe for disaster. The integration of your new hire into the existing team dynamics over the course of 90 days requires thoughtful strategizing. Plan to provide ample support for the new hire as they transition into your company’s culture and work ethos.
  2. Overzealous Acceleration: Condensing a 90-day onboarding process into a week or even a day is detrimental. Onboarding is not merely about task allocation, but also about fostering a culture of belonging and interconnection. Strive for a balance between tasks and relationship building. Remember, successful onboarding should stretch over 90 days to ensure optimal team integration.
  3. Misuse of Personality Tests: Building a robust team isn’t about assembling personalities that you personally resonate with. Instead, use personality tests as tools to understand how the new hire will complement your existing team. Harness this information to facilitate effective connections and provide the necessary support during their onboarding journey.
  4. Neglecting the Experience: As Chip Heath explains in his book ‘The Power of Moments’, crafting memorable experiences is integral to establishing a strong team culture. The initial impression of their first day often echoes throughout the new hire’s tenure. Therefore, ensure the onboarding process is more than just tasks—it should cultivate a culture of clear communication, relationship building, and memorable experiences. (Tip: Add The Power of Moments by Chip Heath to your list of books!)
  5. Task-Oriented Approach: Viewing onboarding merely as a task checklist overlooks its potential as a time for learning, shaping, and growth. Analogous to transplanting a plant, every new hire requires specific care to acclimate to their new environment. Embrace onboarding as a multi-dimensional process that helps the new hire navigate through unfamiliar territory, fostering a sense of belonging and defining their scope of authority.
  6. Lack of Communication Structure Training: The initial onboarding phase should promote open and proactive communication. While encouraging newcomers to ask questions, it’s vital to strike a balance to prevent dependence on us for information. Onboarding should involve offering support as needed, training them gradually, and eventually encouraging autonomy.
  7. Failure to Define Success: Clear expectations of success should be outlined from the outset. Understanding what success looks like to the new hire is equally important. Use this information to create measurable metrics that will guide their performance and accountability.

A well-planned onboarding process can significantly impact a new hire’s journey and overall team success. Keep these common pitfalls in mind, and you’ll be well on your way to fostering a supportive, engaging, and enriching onboarding experience for your new team members.

Revamping Your Approach to Onboarding New Team Members

Creating a comprehensive, meaningful, and enjoyable onboarding experience isn’t just about avoiding mistakes. It also involves actively implementing the best strategies. Let’s focus on how you can transform potential errors into proactive, effective measures to ensure your new team member’s smooth transition into your organization.

  1. Adopting a Phased Approach: Replace the misconception of onboarding as a one-time event with the reality that it’s an ongoing process. Frame onboarding as a journey that continues over several weeks or even months, with planned strategies designed to help the new hire become an integrated part of your team.
  2. Information Management: Instead of overwhelming your new hire with an avalanche of information on their first day, strategically structure the orientation period. Prioritize the most immediate knowledge they need to function and gradually introduce the rest over time.
  3. Cultural Integration: Move beyond the one-size-fits-all onboarding approach and focus on instilling your company’s culture. Facilitate interactions with various teams and departments and encourage the new hire to understand your organization’s values, mission, and work ethos organically.
  4. Encouraging Feedback: To refine your onboarding process, seek feedback from your new team member. Establish regular check-ins, conduct surveys, and encourage open dialogue to understand their experiences, concerns, or suggestions.
  5. Promoting Role Clarity: Don’t just hand over a job description; spend time discussing their role, responsibilities, and performance metrics in detail. Ensure they fully comprehend their function and the impact of their role on the team and the broader organization. This clarity can empower them to be proactive and can enhance their confidence from the get-go.

Incorporating these approaches can effectively transform your onboarding process, creating an enriching and engaging experience that not only helps the new hire adjust quickly but also cultivates their long-term commitment to your team and organization.

Onboarding Best Practices: Crafting a Positive First Impression

  1. Create a Structured Onboarding Program: Plan out a comprehensive onboarding schedule that outlines the first few weeks at the organization. Include a mix of formal training, casual meetups, and time for self-learning.
  2. Provide Necessary Resources: Equip your new hire with the tools they need from the get-go. Whether it’s a laptop, access to software systems, or important reading materials, make sure they have what they need to start their work effectively.
  3. Assign a Mentor or Buddy: Having a go-to person can greatly help the new hire navigate through the early days in the organization. This person can offer guidance, answer questions, and provide moral support, making the new member feel welcomed and valued.
  4. Showcase Your Company Culture: Organize informal gatherings or team activities that highlight your company culture. This helps the new hire to understand the team dynamics and fosters a sense of belonging.
  5. Celebrate Milestones: Celebrating small victories or milestones can boost the new hire’s confidence and reinforce their sense of achievement. It could be the completion of their first project, their first client interaction, or even their first month in the organization.

Remember, the onboarding experience you create for your new team member significantly influences their perception of your organization and their future performance. By avoiding the common mistakes and embracing best practices, you can ensure a positive and fulfilling onboarding journey that nurtures engagement, productivity, and job satisfaction.

Is Your Onboarding Process Successful? Here’s How to Measure Its Success!

Measuring the success of an onboarding program is crucial to ensure that new hires are effectively integrated into the company and set up for success. Here are some key metrics and methods to measure the success of an onboarding program:

  1. New hires’ job satisfaction: Measure the satisfaction of new hires through surveys, feedback sessions, or informal conversations to gauge their level of satisfaction with the onboarding process and their overall experience.
  2. Time to productivity: Track the time it takes for new hires to become fully productive in their roles. This metric can help assess the effectiveness of the onboarding program in equipping new hires with the necessary knowledge and skills to perform their job duties efficiently.
  3. Overall morale: Assess the overall morale of new hires by monitoring their engagement, motivation, and sense of belonging within the company. This can be measured through surveys, feedback sessions, or observation of their interactions with your other team members or contractors.
  4. Employee turnover: Measure the turnover rate of new hires within a specific timeframe, such as the first three to six months. A high turnover rate may indicate that the onboarding program is not effectively retaining new hires or meeting their expectations.
  5. Hiring managers’ performance: Evaluate the performance of hiring managers in terms of their ability to effectively onboard new hires. This can be measured through feedback from new hires, performance reviews, or assessments of the manager’s support and guidance during the onboarding process.

These metrics provide valuable insights into the effectiveness of the onboarding program and help identify areas for improvement. Regularly tracking and analyzing these metrics can help organizations optimize their onboarding processes and enhance the overall experience for new hires

I'm Kaylan, leadership educator, podcaster & speaker

What are you searching for?

Reading suggestions

Crafting a 90-Day Onboarding Plan

Job Postings that Attract Top Talent

Mapping Your Leadership Style